---------------------------------------------------------------------------- From: strikeforce16m@yahoo.com (strikeforce) Date: Fri, 20 Sep 2002 16:05:49 GMT Subject: The Way Things Are(tm) Message-ID: <3d8b475c.6815825@basic.bs.webusenet.com> -------- Fact: This NG has decided to accept books and the EU outside the movies in Star Wars as official and unless directly contradicting the movies can be used as evidence in a debate. Fact: Darkstar does not agree with this NG, believing that since Star Trek cannot accept things outside the movies or shows, neither should Star Wars, no matter what Lucas or others say. Conclusion: Darkstar should not even be participating in any debates on this NG since he doesn't accept evidence that we are allowed to bring up. ---------------------------------------------------------------------------- From: "DarkStar" Date: Sat, 21 Sep 2002 14:33:05 GMT Subject: Re: The Way Things Are(tm) Message-ID: -------- "strikeforce" wrote in message news:3d8b475c.6815825@basic.bs.webusenet.com... > Fact: This NG has decided to accept books and the EU outside the > movies in Star Wars as official and unless directly contradicting the > movies can be used as evidence in a debate. True. > > Fact: Darkstar does not agree with this NG, believing that since Star > Trek cannot accept things outside the movies or shows, neither should > Star Wars, no matter what Lucas or others say. False. > > Conclusion: Darkstar should not even be participating in any debates > on this NG since he doesn't accept evidence that we are allowed to > bring up. > You cannot arrive at a valid conclusion with a blatantly false premise. ---------------------------------------------------------------------------- From: "WeeMadAndo" Date: Sun, 22 Sep 2002 00:44:32 +1000 Subject: Re: The Way Things Are(tm) Message-ID: -------- "DarkStar" wrote in message news:Aq%i9.185394$AR1.7809434@bin2.nnrp.aus1.giganews.com... > > "strikeforce" wrote in message > news:3d8b475c.6815825@basic.bs.webusenet.com... > > Fact: This NG has decided to accept books and the EU outside the > > movies in Star Wars as official and unless directly contradicting the > > movies can be used as evidence in a debate. > > True. And its LucasFilms canon policy to boot... > > Fact: Darkstar does not agree with this NG, believing that since Star > > Trek cannot accept things outside the movies or shows, neither should > > Star Wars, no matter what Lucas or others say. > > False. But that is Paramounts canon policy. Its not OUR problem. > > Conclusion: Darkstar should not even be participating in any debates > > on this NG since he doesn't accept evidence that we are allowed to > > bring up. > > > > You cannot arrive at a valid conclusion with a blatantly false premise. Whats false? -- WeeMadAndo Blue sparks and white smoke, the two most expensive components of any electrical system. Once you've used them, it costs a fortune to replace them. ---------------------------------------------------------------------------- From: "DarkStar" Date: Sat, 21 Sep 2002 22:48:37 GMT Subject: Re: The Way Things Are(tm) Message-ID: <9H6j9.187641$z91.7906499@bin3.nnrp.aus1.giganews.com> -------- "WeeMadAndo" wrote in message news:ami0hv$63vhr$1@ID-21694.news.dfncis.de... > "DarkStar" wrote in message > news:Aq%i9.185394$AR1.7809434@bin2.nnrp.aus1.giganews.com... > > > > "strikeforce" wrote in message > > news:3d8b475c.6815825@basic.bs.webusenet.com... > > > Fact: This NG has decided to accept books and the EU outside the > > > movies in Star Wars as official and unless directly contradicting the > > > movies can be used as evidence in a debate. > > > > True. > > And its LucasFilms canon policy to boot... False. > > > > Fact: Darkstar does not agree with this NG, believing that since Star > > > Trek cannot accept things outside the movies or shows, neither should > > > Star Wars, no matter what Lucas or others say. > > > > False. > > But that is Paramounts canon policy. Its not OUR problem. No, no, you weren't listening . . . his claim about my belief is false. ---------------------------------------------------------------------------- From: mikewongisgod@hotmail.com (RayCav) Date: 22 Sep 2002 09:19:32 -0700 Subject: Re: The Way Things Are(tm) Message-ID: -------- "DarkStar" wrote in message news:<9H6j9.187641$z91.7906499@bin3.nnrp.aus1.giganews.com>... > "WeeMadAndo" wrote in message > news:ami0hv$63vhr$1@ID-21694.news.dfncis.de... > > "DarkStar" wrote in message > > news:Aq%i9.185394$AR1.7809434@bin2.nnrp.aus1.giganews.com... > > > > > > "strikeforce" wrote in message > > > news:3d8b475c.6815825@basic.bs.webusenet.com... > > > > Fact: DarkStar is a retarded Trekkie wanker. > > > > > > True. > > > > But it's his policy to change that. > > False. > > > > > > > Fact: DarkStar is a homo. > > > > > > False. > > > > But that is your canon policy. Its not OUR problem. > > No, no, you weren't listening . . . I was still talking about being a wanker. DarkStar, ladies and gentlemen.....